Property Taxes in Cook County
Supplementary Data & Analysis
Background Information
The following materials are a work in progress based on property tax data released by the Cook County Assessor’s Office (CCAO) and other publicly available data sources. Much of the incorporated data and analysis was prepared, in part, for Cook County’s Property Tax Working Group. This data and analysis accompanies and supplements information in the Exemption White Paper and Addendum, available on GFRC’s website.
We are especially indebted to the maintainers of the Cook County Assessor’s Office Github and the developers and maintainers of PTAXSIM, a package in the R programming language which provides the public with a trove of historical property tax data, without which this analysis would not be possible.
We would also like to thank Professors Merriman, Weber, Carroll, and Drucker from UIC’s College of Urban Planning and Public Policy for their support as well as the Chicago Metropolitan Agency for Planning (CMAP) for providing supplemental and background analysis.
All data was originally posted by the Cook County Assessor’s Office (CCAO) or available on the Cook County Data Catalog.
All summarizing of data was done by Research Assistants working for the Government Finance Research Center at the University of Illinois Chicago.
Incentive Report
Read the The Current and Future Use of Incentives in Cook County report here and view all supporting figures and tables for tax year 2022 and yearly trends and analysis mentioned in the report.
Exemption Report Summary of Findings
UIC’s research led to several main findings:
While historical records provide clear reasons for the adoption of homeowner exemptions as a policy tool, current stakeholders throughout Cook County government cannot agree on the public purpose of homestead exemptions, a problem that flows through to properly acknowledging relevant costs, benefits, and stakeholders. Indeed, given divergent policy goals by different stakeholders, any construct of “effectiveness” would be challenging to measure.
Cook County’s property tax system allocates revenue to local governments based on each property owners’ share of that jurisdiction’s total tax base.
CC’s system of dividing the levy among property owners creates a “zero-sum” game where one taxpayer’s bill must necessarily increase for another taxpayer’s bill to decrease.
Homeowner exemptions, designed to provide tax release to certain classes of homeowners, decrease property tax bills through a flat reduction in the taxpayer’s contribution to the tax base in EAV.
Exemptions also reduce the tax base, thereby driving tax rates up for all taxpayers (even those that receive exemptions). This push-pull effect causes the true amount of tax liability reduction to be sometimes significantly lower than suggested by government tax bills.
Exemptions are theoretically and practically progressive, bringing greater tax relief to those with the lowest ability to pay (as imperfectly measured by their property’s value).
Anomalous outcomes can occur due to Cook County’s socio-economic homogeneity. A handful of taxpayers would benefit more from exemptions’ elimination (and the resulting decrease in tax rate) than from the exemption itself.
There is no obvious solution to the detrimental effects of exemptions that are endogenous to the property tax system. Any “fix” must come from other revenue.
We have also appended an explanation of our data sources and how we prepared that data for analysis as well as a mathematical appendix of tedious equations.